Should Neleh Have Won?

[Zarya]

Neleh should have won. If she never joined Vee to overthrow the Rotu 4, Vee will never be in Final 2 place. Too bad some of the jury had grudge against her.

[nix]

i thought neleh shuld have won.. coz in my opinion vee didn't do that much in the game

neleh was heaps gud so was pappy!!

[Tennis Ace]

VECEPIA>>>>neleh

[bill'swife]

Oh yeah!!! I'm glad Vecepia won!!! She's more deserving than some others!!!

[Zarya]

Yes ... Vee is a worthy winner. But somehow I love to see Neleh won more. It's not that Vee's winning is bad but it's a matter of my personal feeling. That's it.

[swongq]

Have you seen a picture of Vee lately? Boy she has changed since gave birth to her first child.

[Zarya]

No not yet,do you know where I can see those pics swongq?

[Tia]

yea vee has changed but she did deserve to win, I am so grateful to kathy didnt win. I always was cheerin 4 her shes my black sister. i didnt really like any1 else but her and sean but, i didnt really "get" tht season cos it was my first

[Shannon]

Vee = Winner Mee = Happy

[5Crocodiles4U]

After all this time, I still think Kathy should have won Marquesas. SHe CARRIED Vee and Neleh to the final, they rode her coattails. It's too bad Kathy let Neleh distract her in the final IC, she should've won that, being physically stronger than either Vee or Neleh.
 
Kathy not winning S4 was the BIGGEST disappointment in Survivor History.(Terry not winning S12 being the second biggest).

[hobbes08]

Well, V and Sean took the initiative to bring Kathy, Paschal, and Neleh over to their side....

[Jeff]

Actually, it from BRob that tried to flip Kathy. Kathy did all the work to flip Paschal and Neleh. Also, Kathy realized she was first on the chopping block when the merge came and didn't need Sean and Vee for that.

Sean and Vee knew what was going on, but sat back and waited for it to come. Kathy did all the work to save her ass and the asses of Sean, Vee, Paschal, and Neleh.

I wanted Kathy to win, but in the end, it was Kathy's fault she didn't win. Out of Vee and Neleh, they were evenly matched, but I'm fine with Vee winning.

[5Crocodiles4U]

Kathy did realise she was in trouble at the merge. She hung in there and won the first IC at the merge.
 
She did do all the work to sway Neleh and Paschal.  Neleh wasn't smart enough to figure it out and Paschal wasn't aggressive enough to do anything until Kathy finally made them see the light.

[TeKnight]

Vee Won?  Oh yeah right ZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

I'm still a fan of the Winner actually doing something to win. Vee was hardly a "Player"

Which is why, even though I was rooting for Terry I'm not disappointed that Ares won.  He Played and that's what really counts.  I really can't remember Vee ever doing anything, even stirring the pot like Cirie!  

Vee = ZZZZZZZZZZZZZ  

[5Crocodiles4U]

Still Vee was a better winner than Am-Bore(S8).  I don't think there is was or ever will be a Survivor as useless as Am-Bore, the WORST WINNER EVER! But Vee was pretty useless too, she rode Kathy's coattails to the win, doing nothing herself.