If the casting would have been up to you

[5Crocodiles4U]

I agree with a few of the casting choices for Heroes and Villans but not all of them.  Here is who I would have picked for Heroes and Villans if it had been my choice:
 
Heroes:
 
1. Yul Kwon(Best player EVER IMHO)
2. Yau-Man Chan
3. Terry Dietz
4. Jonathan Penner
5. Colby Donaldson
6. Amanda Kimmel
7. Peih-Gee Law
8. Danielle Boatwright(Best female player EVER IMHO)
9. Kelly Wiggeslworth
10. Eliza Orlins
 
 
Villans:
 
1.  Russell Hantz
2.  Ben "Coach" Wade
3.  Shane Powers
4.  Lex VanDenBerghe
5. "Boston Rob" Mariano
6.  Jerri Manthey
7.  Natalie Bolton
8.  Corrine Kaplan
9.  Stephenie LaGrossa(she's actually more villan than hero IMHO)
10. Heidi Hamels (I forgot her maiden name she was in S6 with Jenna Morasca she's now married to Philles pitcher Cole Hamels)
 
I think these are much moire compelling than some of the others picked.  What do you guys think?

[DMC05]

Its Heidi Strobel if I'm not wrong.

[ChilltownRobot]

I'll take a shot at this
Heroes:
Colby
Yau-Man
Ian
Pascal
Stephan
Amanda
Kelly W
Alexis
Eliza
Natalie(Samoa)

Villians:
Fairplay
Cesternino
Greg Buis
Boston Rob
Hatch
Parvati
Natalie(FVF)
Jerri
Ami
Kelly G

[DMC05]

Trivia: Yau-Man was asked, but couldn't accept since he was out of leave for the duration.

[Strategy1st]

Aww, that's good to know, since I was surprised he wasn't included this time around.

[5Crocodiles4U]

Thanks. It would have been nice to have Yau-Man back but if he couldn't do it he couldn't do it.
 
Overall, I think the cast they picked is ok.  Would rather have seen Yul and Terry on the heroes than Tom Westman and JT
but they're all right.
 
I'm kind of liking Tom Westman this time around, maybe he's not so bad.
 
As for Rupert I'm just waiting for the merge and seeing him get porked by Russell if they both make the merge.
 
I do like the villans better though.  The only heroes I really like are Colby and Amanda.
 
As for the villans, Russell and Boston Rob RULE!!!!!
I actually like Boston Rob now and think he is way cool.
The only villan I don't like is Tyson.

[DMC05]

(Strategy1st @ Feb. 17 2010,08:16)

QUOTE

Aww, that's good to know, since I was surprised he wasn't included this time around.

Indeed, you'd think of him immediately when asked of Survivor Heroes. Was surprised he wasn't there but then again, figured that it probably was due to the player's commitment or something.